TL;DR
You need both, but your website should come first. Your website is your owned, controllable home base that works 24/7. Social media is great for engagement but you don't own it and algorithms limit your reach. Build your website, then use social media to drive traffic to it.
The Key Difference: Owned vs Rented
Your Website = Owned Media
You control everything:
- Design and branding
- Content and messaging
- Customer data
- How visitors find and contact you
- No algorithm deciding who sees what
Social Media = Rented Space
You're subject to:
- Platform rules and changes
- Algorithm whims (2-5% organic reach on Facebook)
- Limited customization
- Risk of account suspension
- No ownership of your audience
What Each Does Best
Websites Excel At:
- Credibility: 84% of consumers trust websites more than social media
- SEO: Getting found by people searching for your services
- Conversion: Turning visitors into customers with clear CTAs
- Information: Providing detailed service and pricing info
- Lead capture: Collecting emails and inquiries 24/7
- Professionalism: Making a strong first impression
Social Media Excels At:
- Engagement: Two-way conversations with customers
- Community: Building relationships and loyalty
- Awareness: Reaching new audiences through sharing
- Updates: Quick announcements and behind-the-scenes content
- Social proof: Showing your active, engaged customer base
- Personality: Humanizing your brand
The Winning Strategy: Website First, Social Second
Here's why this order matters:
1. Capture the Traffic You Generate
Without a website, where do you send interested people from social media? A Facebook page? That keeps them in Facebook's ecosystem, not yours.
With a website, every social post can drive traffic to pages designed to convert.
2. Build Your Email List
Social media followers aren't yours—you can't contact them directly. A website lets you collect email addresses, building an asset you own.
3. Rank in Search Results
Social profiles rarely rank for "plumber near me" or "landscaper in [city]." Websites do. Local search is where ready-to-buy customers are looking.
4. Present Complete Information
A website lets you showcase:
- Full service descriptions
- Pricing information
- Portfolio of work
- Testimonials and reviews
- FAQs
- Contact options
Trying to fit all this in social media is clunky and ineffective.
How to Use Them Together
Your Website Should:
- Be your conversion hub
- Contain detailed information
- Capture leads and inquiries
- Rank for relevant searches
- Link to your social profiles
Your Social Media Should:
- Drive traffic to your website
- Share snippets that intrigue (full story on website)
- Engage with comments and messages
- Share customer testimonials (linked to reviews page)
- Show personality and behind-the-scenes
Real-World Example
Without a website:
Customer sees your Facebook post → browses your page → gets distracted by other content → leaves
With a website:
Customer sees your Facebook post → clicks link to your website → reads your services → fills out contact form → becomes a lead
Budget Considerations
If budget is tight, here's the priority order:
- Professional website (one-time investment, works forever)
- Google Business Profile (free, essential for local search)
- One social platform done well (where your customers actually are)
Better to have a great website and one good social presence than mediocre everything.
Common Mistakes
- Social-only strategy: Leaves money on the table
- Website without social: Misses engagement opportunities
- Spreading too thin: 5 mediocre social accounts vs 1 great one
- Not linking social to website: Keeping traffic in social silos
- Ignoring Google Business Profile: Free and often more valuable than social
The Bottom Line
Website first, social second. Your website is your 24/7 salesperson that you own and control. Social media amplifies your reach and builds relationships. Together, they create a complete online presence.
[Get Your Free Website Review →](/contact)